Skip to main content

Sentencing Commission findings underline need for decisive reform of Scotland’s justice system

NEWS | 6th February 2026

Change of focus to community sentencing can create a system “fit for the 21st Century”

A group of gardeners being supervised as part of their unpaid work requirement

Following the report published today by the Sentencing and Penal Policy Commission, Community Justice Scotland (CJS) has said it will continue to work closely with partner organisations to create a justice system that reduces harm, cuts costs, and delivers better outcomes for individuals and communities.

Karyn McCluskey, Chief Executive of CJS said: “Community justice works — the evidence shows that time and again. Community sentences are tough and transformative: they hold people accountable while connecting them to housing, treatment, employment, and a sense of purpose.

“The Commission’s report will rightly receive close scrutiny, with careful attention paid to its implications for victims, people accused of offences, communities, public finances, and the practicalities of implementation. None of this will be quick. It will take commitment, investment, and a delivery plan that keeps pace with the ambition set out in the report.

“This report makes clear that the time has come for decisive, evidence based reform that will create a Scottish justice system fit for the 21st century. It presents a rare opportunity for us all: a chance to step back from the noise and ask what kind of justice system — and what kind of society — we want for Scotland’s future.”